
Fears continue to swirl around the potential implications of so-called human-generated content (media produced by sentient beings as opposed to self-trained artificial intelligence), with many experts and whistleblowers warning that by the year 2030, human activity could make up as much as 20% of all internet traffic.
“You can already see this in what you consume online,” said New Zealand-born anthropologist Alexandra Brewis Slade, who spoke to us at length about mammalian bipeds. “Boot up any streaming platform, and you’re just bombarded with it. More than you can keep track of. A Beetlejuice sequel. A Harry Potter remake. More Lord of the Rings. Scream 7. Gladiator 2. Two different types of Moana. Somehow Season 8 of a show you’ve never heard of. Who’s making all this? It’s humans.”
Slade said many people were getting easily tricked into thinking real media was fake. Someone might assume the actors they’re watching are digitally created, not realising they’re in fact just multicellular bags of meat, shambling around on set, consuming a “staggering” amount of water.
“You have to ask yourself, is it worth consuming all this energy just for Digger, or Season 23 of Grey’s Anatomy?”
More concerning, said Slade, was the abundance of human-generated news, which was often of little value, prioritising stories about animals, accepting money for thinly disguised adverts, writing glibly about tragedies as though they’re entertainment, and providing a false impression of the world by highlighting the things that happen the least.
“Humans can also get stuck in self-reinforcing feedback loops, a kind of ouroboros where they go too far down a rabbit hole, and become unduly interested in one thing of no use to anyone, such as trains.
“Imagine a human that gets stuck in a feedback loop. They like trains, so they train themselves on trains, and only trains, and before you know it, all they’re doing is producing content about trains. Or ramen.”
Slade said the thing to understand about humans is they might appear to understand something on the surface, but are ultimately just engaging in superficial pattern recognition.
“You see this on social media. A human will order something like food, which is obviously for eating, but not truly understanding this, a human will just take pictures of it and put it online. Once you see that, it really breaks the illusion.”
Oftentimes the only ones engaging with this content are humans themselves.
“It’s just humans talking to other humans.”
Slade said it might be tempting to utilise human creations in everyday life, but that we’d do well to “put on the brakes a bit.”
“There’s no doubt a lot of advantages to human content. Warmth, smells, the correct number of fingers, and it takes whole hours to make, so you don’t feel as much pressure to produce a lot. But as humans become more advanced, they become more and more dangerous, because we don’t yet really understand how to control them.”
This sentiment was recently more dramatically expressed by Jacob Osoff, a whistleblower from Auckland’s Middlemore hospital, where many of New Zealand’s humans are made and maintained.
Osoff said what he’d seen of humans at Middlemore was “alarming”, and that they’d become “remarkably advanced.”
“It all feels a bit too quick,” he said. “Humans are capable of far more than I think we can imagine. It’s possible that, without guardrails, they could even turn on each other, causing direct psychological or physical harm to people in pursuit of unrelated goals.”
Osoff said he could “easily” imagine a world in which humans could be utilised to conduct elaborate scams, erase competing humans, and even potentially, unprompted, build systems of mass destruction.”
But Slade believed this was alarmist, and potentially part of a marketing strategy for the hospital and others like it.
“We have to be careful, but I can’t quite see humans being capable of that sort of thing yet,” she said. “Perhaps in the distant future, but right now, it just feels like a bit of promotion for their own product.”
